The thyroid, iodine and breast cancer
Breast Cancer Research volume 5, Article number: 235 (2003)
A renewal of the search for a link between breast cancer and thyroid disease has once again demonstrated an increased prevalence of autoimmune thyroid disease in patients with breast cancer. This is the most recent of many studies showing an association between a variety of thyroid disorders and breast cancer. Such an association is not surprising as both diseases are female predominant with a similar postmenopausal peak incidence. The significance of the presence of thyroid autoantibodies, particularly thyroid peroxidase antibodies, in serum from patients with breast cancer is unknown, but it has been suggested that antibody positivity is associated with better prognosis. One area in which thyroid and breast functions overlap is in the uptake and utilization of dietary iodide. Experimental findings showing the ability of iodine or iodine-rich seaweed to inhibit breast tumour development is supported by the relatively low rate of breast cancer in Japanese women who consume a diet containing iodine-rich seaweed. However, there is as yet no direct evidence that iodine, iodinated compounds, or a combination of iodine and selenium is the antimammary carcinogenic element in the Japanese diet. It remains to be resolved whether the perceived breast cancer–thyroid disease relationship is thyroid or iodine related or, in the case of thyroid autoantibodies, is the consequence of an immune response to the carcinoma. Is this response breast specific and does it relate to iodine status? These and many other questions await resolution before a definitive role in the natural history of breast carcinoma can be assigned to the thyroid.
In this issue of Breast Cancer Research Turken and coworkers  describe an association between breast cancer and autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD), showing not only an increased prevalence of thyroid peroxidase (TPO) antibodies in patients with breast cancer but also a significantly increased rate of goiter (diffuse 8%, nodular 50%) as compared with control individuals (4% and 26%, respectively). This finding is in agreement with previous studies [2, 3] that showed both increased goiter rates and increased prevalence of thyroid enlargement by ultrasound in patients with breast cancer . This association represents yet another page in the continuing saga of the perceived coincidence between breast cancer and diseases of the thyroid gland. The fact that both breast cancer and thyroid disease predominantly affect females and that both have a postmenopausal peak incidence has inevitably resulted in a search for an association between the two diseases [5, 6]. Although many studies have shown such an association, evidence of specific causal linkage between thyroid breast cancer and thyroid disease continues to be elusive.
One of the earliest reports on the association of breast cancer with thyroid disease was that from Beatson  in 1896, who used oopherectomy and thyroid extract to treat breast cancer. Since that report there have been many studies showing an association of breast cancer with hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism, thyroxine replacement therapy and thyroiditis [5, 6]. Equally, other reports showed no significant association. Where an association between thyroid disease and breast cancer was shown to exist, hypothyroidism was the most frequently observed finding. In fact, many reports considered hyperthyroidism to be protective against breast cancer because progression of such cancers was more frequently observed when the hyperthyroidism was treated .
The increased frequency of thyroid autoantibodies, TPO antibodies and thyroglobulin antibodies described by Turken and coworkers  in breast cancer patients as compared with control individuals supports earlier findings [8–11]. Such differences were not observed for other autoimmune antibodies . The use of specific immunoassays for TPO antibodies and thyroglobulin antibodies  revealed an increased prevalence of TPO antibodies in breast cancer. Although the presence of circulating TPO antibodies in asymptomatic individuals has been implicated as conferring an increased risk for future hypothyroidism , there is no agreement on the significance of its association with breast cancer . A fivefold excess in breast cancer has been reported in Japanese patients with AITD . However, no significant association between breast cancer and Hashimoto's thyroiditis was reported in a study from the Mayo Clinic in the USA . Thus, like other reported associations, the relationship between AITD, iodine intake and breast cancer is far from clear. Equally, there is little agreement on the significance of any published association between a range of thyroid disorders and breast cancer [5, 6].
The possibility that hypothyroidism might in itself have been beneficial in terms of outcome of breast cancer has been suggested . Recent reports from our laboratory  have shown that the presence of TPO antibodies is associated with a significant improvement in both disease-free and overall outcome in breast cancer patients, and that the magnitude of this prognostic effect was of a similar order of magnitude to well established prognostic indices for breast cancer such as axillary nodal status or tumour size. Thus, we have the anomalous situation in which the presence of TPO antibodies, while being associated with breast cancer, also appears to confer prognostic benefits. A recent review that contained a meta-analysis of published work on breast–thyroid associations  found no significant association between the two disorders and attributed any positive findings of such an association to 'selection or institutional referral bias'. This negative finding was immediately followed by communications [1, 17] reaffirming the association of breast cancer with hypothyroidism and AITD. It is therefore apparent that the argument about breast–thyroid associations is far from resolved.
The association of thyroid antibody positivity, sometimes with transient thyroid dysfunction, has been reported in the course of immunotherapy with recombinant cytokines interleukin-2 and interferon-α for various cancers [18, 19]. Thyroid antibody related hypothyroidism has been suggested as being associated with a favourable tumour response to such therapies. In a recent report  it was shown in metastatic renal cell carcinoma that the presence of a positive thyroid antibody titre, either pre-existing or cytokine induced, was a highly significant independent prognostic factor. In the case of thyroid autoantibodies being associated with better disease outcome in breast cancer, renal carcinoma or melanoma, it is possible that the immune response to thyroid and tumour tissue might be similarly regulated in that it might be directed against both tumour and thyroid antigens. Another possibility is that both tumour and thyroid share the same antigens because expression of the sodium–iodide symporter has been demonstrated in both thyroid and breast tissues [20–22].
One area in which thyroid and breast functions overlap is in the uptake and utilization of iodide. In the thyroid, I- is required for thyroid hormonogenesis whereas in the breast I- is needed in breast milk as a source of neonatal nutrition. Both organs require a method of oxidizing I- to I2 (organification) in order to produce iodoproteins [23, 24]. This involves the presence of H2O2 as an oxidizing agent catalyzed by TPO in the thyroid and by lactoperoxidases in the breast. Apart from the requirement for iodide as a nutrient in breast milk, there is no known role for iodine in the normal or diseased breast. However, a breast requirement for I2 rather than I- has been suggested . It has been postulated that formation of iodolipids such as iodolactones or iodoaldehydes represents a form of thyroidal autoregulation , which may be the mode of action of iodide inhibition of thyroid function in the Wolff–Chaikoff effect [27–29].
In addition to their role in inhibiting thyroid function, these compounds may act as antiproliferative agents in the thyroid . Iodinated compounds (so-called XI) may exert inhibitory effects on adenylate cyclase, NADPH (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate, reduced form)-oxidase and TPO activities . This effect seems to require oxidation of I- to I2 because inhibitors of TPO or I- trapping can reverse the inhibitory effect . It has also been suggested that such inhibitory actions of iodo-compounds on cell proliferation might play a role in the breast [30, 31]. Some support for a role for iodine in the human breast is provided by our own findings , which showed that tissue iodine levels were relatively low in patients with breast cancer as compared with normal tissues or benign breast tumours (fibroadenomata). We have also recently shown 125I uptake blocking effects in sera from 19% of 105 patients with breast cancer , as compared with a published prevalence of 30.7% of such blocking activity, believed to be of immunogenic origin, in Graves' disease . The ability of the breast to express sodium–iodide symporter [20–22] and, at least in lactation, to take up significant amounts of iodide has led to studies of the potential for use of 131I ablative therapy in breast cancer, analogous to that employed in the treatment of hyperthyroidism or thyroid cancer.
An anticarcinogenic role for iodine in experimental animals was suggested by the work of Funahashi and coworkers , who found that administration of Lugol's iodine or iodine-rich Wakame seaweed to rats treated with the carcinogen dimethyl benzanthracene suppressed the development of mammary tumours. In further studies , the same group demonstrated that seaweed induced apoptosis in human breast cancer cells with greater potency than that of fluorouracil, a chemotherapeutic agent used to treat breast cancer. This finding led the authors to speculate that 'seaweed may be applicable for prevention of breast cancer'.
This hypothesis is in accord with the relatively low breast cancer rate reported in Japan , where the normal diet is seaweed rich, and with increasing breast cancer rates in Japanese women who emigrate  or consume a western style diet . Interestingly this finding applies to rates of breast cancer in both males and females . This evidence favours the low rate of breast cancer being environmental rather than genetic in origin. One of the main dietary differences between Japanese and western women is the consumption of large amounts of iodine-rich seaweeds by the former, yielding a dietary iodine intake of several milligrams per day in Japanese women as compared with microgram quantities in western women . Of course it must be stressed that all this evidence is circumstantial because the contribution, if any, of dietary iodine intake to these findings is unknown. Equally, the possibility that this protective effect may be lost in patients with AITD  remains to be explored.
The frequent coexistence of iodine and selenium deficiencies and the importance of replacing both to maintain thyroid function is well established . It has also been suggested that a combined iodine–selenium deficiency may facilitate the development of breast cancer . Selenium deficiency results in diminution of selenium-containing antioxidative enzymes such as glutathione peroxidase, deiodinases and thioredoxine reductases [39, 40], leading to increased levels of reactive oxygen species. These oxidants can inactivate many enzymes, are a feature of lipid peroxidation and DNA damage, and have been shown to be associated with carcinogenesis in the breast . On the other hand, increased serum levels of antioxidants have been associated with reductions in breast cancer risk . There is also some evidence that iodide itself may act as an antioxidant . Selenium deficiency is associated with AITD perhaps as a result of increased inflammatory activity arising from decreased activity of selenium containing antioxidative enzymes such as glutathione peroxidase , whereas increasing dietary selenium or administration of selenomethionine have also been reported to diminish TPO antibody levels [44, 45].
Although there is as yet no definitive evidence of a role for the thyroid in the natural history of breast cancer, the continuing reports of an association such as that in this issue of Breast Cancer Research  should not be ignored. In particular, the question of whether the presence of TPO antibodies in serum of patients with breast cancer is breast specific or part of a generalized immunogenic response needs to be explored. Also requiring study are the involvement of iodide transport in the breast and additional roles for iodinated compounds within the mammary glands, with their accompanying benefit of providing a new therapeutic pathway for radioiodine ablative therapy. Finally, it remains to be established whether iodide or selenium treatment has prophylactic potential. Whatever the future study pathways, there is little doubt that the perceived association of two of the most common female disorders will continue to intrigue investigators.
autoimmune thyroid disease
Turken O, Narin Y, Demirbas S, Onde ME, Sayan O, Kandemir EG, Yalaci M, Ozturk A: Breast cancer in association with thyroid disorders. Breast Cancer Res. 2003, 5: R110-R113. 10.1186/bcr609.
Bogardus GM, Finley JW: Breast cancer and thyroid disease. Surgery. 1961, 49: 461-468.
Adamopoulos DA, Vassilarus S, Kapolla N, Papadiamantis J, Georgiakodis F, Michalkis A: Thyroid disease in patients with benign and malignant mastopathy. Cancer. 1986, 57: 125-128.
Smyth PPA, Smith D, McDermott E, Murray M, Geraghty J, O'Higgins N: A direct relationship between thyroid enlargement and breast cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1996, 81: 937-941. 10.1210/jc.81.3.937.
Goldman ME: Thyroid diseases and breast cancer. Epidemiol Rev. 1990, 12: 16-28.
Smyth PPA: The thyroid and breast cancer: a significant association? [Editorial]. Ann Med. 1997, 29: 189-191.
Beatson GT: On the treatment of inoperable cases of carcinoma of the mamma: suggestions for a new method of treatment, with illustrative cases. Lancet. 1896, ii: 104-110.
Itoh K, Maruchi N: Breast cancer in patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Lancet. 1975, ii: 1119-1121. 10.1016/S0140-6736(75)91006-5.
Rasmusson B, Feldt-Rasmussen U, Hegedus L, Perrild H, Bech K, Hoier-Madsen M: Thyroid function in patients with breast cancer. Eur J Cancer Clin Oncol. 1987, 23: 553-556.
Giani C, Fierabracci P, Bonacci R, Gigliotti A, Campani D, De Negri F, Cecchetti D, Martino E, Pinchera A: Relationship between breast cancer and thyroid disease: relevance of autoimmune thyroid disorders in breast malignancy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1996, 81: 990-994. 10.1210/jc.81.3.990.
Smyth PPA, Shering S, Kilbane MT, Murray MJ, McDermott EWM, Smith DF, O'Higgins NJ: Serum thyroid peroxidase autoantibodies, thyroid volume and outcome in breast cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1998, 83: 2711-2716. 10.1210/jc.83.8.2711.
Beever K, Bradbury J, Phillips D, McLachlan SM, Pegg C, Goral A, Overbeck W, Feifel G, Smith BR: Highly sensitive assays of autoantibodies to thyroglobulin and to thyroid peroxidase. Clin Chem. 1989, 35: 1949-1954.
Vanderpump MPJ, Tunbridge WMG: The epidemiology of autoimmune thyroid disease. In Contemporary Endocrinology: Autoimmune Endocrinopathies. Edited by: Totowa, NJ: Humana Press. 1999, Volpe R, 141-162.
Sarlis NJ, Gourgiotis L, Pucino F, Tolis GJ: Lack of association between Hashimoto thyroiditis and breast cancer: a quantitive research synthesis. Hormones. 2002, 1: 35-41.
Maruchi N, Annegers JF, Kurland LT: Hashimoto's thyroiditis and breast cancer. Mayo Clin Proc. 1976, 51: 263-265.
Hercbergs A: Hypothyroidism and tumor regression [letter]. N Engl J Med. 1988, 319: 1351-1352.
Cristofanilli M, Yamamura Y, Kau SW, Bevers TB, Strom SS, Patangan MG, Hsu LM, Hrishnamurty S, Hortobagyi GN: Thyroid hormones and breast cancer: primary hypothyroidism is associated with a reduced incidence of primary breast cancer [abstract]. Proc Am Assoc Cancer Res. 2003, 444: 663-
Weijl NI, Van der Harst D, Brand A, Kooy Y, Van Luxemburg S, Schroder J, Lentjes E, Van Rood JJ, Cleton FJ, Osanto S: Hypothyroidism during immunotherapy with interleukin-2 is associated with antithyroid antibodies and response to treatment. J Clin Oncol. 1993, 11: 1376-1383.
Franzke A, Peest D, Probst-Kepper M, Buer J, Kirchner GI, Brabant G, Kirchner H, Ganser A, Atzpodien J: Autoimmunity resulting from cytokine treatment predicts long-term survival in patients with metastatic renal cell cancer. J Clin Oncol. 1999, 7: 529-533.
Kilbane MT, Ajjan RA, Weetman AP, Dwyer R, McDermott EWM, O'Higgins NJ, Smyth PPA: Tissue iodine content and serum mediated 125 I uptake blocking activity in breast cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2000, 85: 1245-1250. 10.1210/jc.85.3.1245.
Tazebay UH, Wapnir IL, Levy O, Dohan O, Zuckier LS, Zhao QH, Deng HF, Amenta PS, Fineberg S, Pestell RG, Carrasco N: The mammary gland iodide transporter is expressed during lactation and in breast cancer. Nat Med. 2000, 6: 871-878. 10.1038/78630.
Wapnir IL, van de Rijn M, Nowels K, Amenta PS, Walton K, Montgomery K, Greco RS, Dohan O, Carrasco N: Immunohistochem-ical profile of the sodium/iodide symporter in thyroid, breast, and other carcinomas using high density tissue microarrays and conventional sections. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2003, 88: 1880-1888. 10.1210/jc.2002-021544.
Taurog A: Hormone synthesis: thyroid iodine metabolism. In Werner and Ingbar's The Thyroid. Edited by: Braverman L, Utiger RD. 1996, Philadelphia: Lippincott Co, 47-81.
Shah NM, Eskin BA, Krouse TB, Sparks CE: Iodoprotein formation by rat mammary glands during pregnancy and early post-partum period. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med. 1986, 181: 443-449.
Eskin BA, Grotkowski CE, Connolly CP, Ghent WR: Different tissue responses for iodine and iodide in rat thyroid and mammary glands. Biol Trace Elem Res. 1995, 49: 9-19.
Dugrillon A: Iodolactones and iodoaldehydes-mediators of iodine in thyroid autoregulation. Exp Clin Endocrinol Diabetes. 1996, Suppl 4: 41-45.
Denef JF, Many MC, van den Hove MF: Iodine-induced thyroid inhibition and cell necrosis: two consequences of the same free-radical mediated mechanism?. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 1996, 121: 101-103. 10.1016/0303-7207(96)03848-8.
Wolff J, Chaikoff IL: Plasma inorganic iodide as a homeostatic regulator of thyroid function. J Biol Chem. 1948, 174: 555-560.
Vitale M, Di Matola T, D'Ascoli F, Salzano S, Bogazzi F, Fenzi G, Martino E, Rossi G: Iodide excess induces apoptosis in thyroid cells through a p53-independent mechanism involving oxidative stress. Endocrinology. 2000, 141: 598-605. 10.1210/en.141.2.598.
Venturi S: Is there a role for iodine in breast diseases?. The Breast. 2001, 10: 379-382. 10.1054/brst.2000.0267.
Cann SA, van Netten JP, van Netten C: Hypothesis: Iodine, selenium and the development of breast cancer. Cancer Causes Control. 2000, 11: 121-127. 10.1023/A:1008925301459.
Ajjan RA, Findlay C, Metcalfe RA, Watson PF, Crisp M, Ludgate M, Weetman AP: The modulation of the human sodium iodide symporter activity by Graves' disease sera. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1998, 83: 1217-1221. 10.1210/jc.83.4.1217.
Funahashi H: Wakame seaweed suppresses the proliferation of 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)-anthracene-induced mammary tumours in rats. Jpn J Cancer Res. 1999, 90: 992-997.
Funahashi H, Imai T, Mase T, Sekiya M, Yokoi K, Hayashi H, Shibata A, Hayashi T, Nishikawa M, Suda N, Hibi Y, Mizuno Y, Tsukamura K, Hayakawa A, Tanuma S: Seaweed prevents breast cancer?. Jpn J Cancer Res. 2001, 92: 483-487.
Pisani P, Parkin DM, Bray F, Ferlay J: Estimates of the worldwide mortality from 25 cancers in 1990. Int J Cancer. 1999, 83: 18-29. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0215(19990924)83:1<18::AID-IJC5>3.3.CO;2-D.
Le Marchand L, Kolonel LN, Nomura AM: Breast cancer survival among Hawaii Japanese and Caucasian women. Ten year rates and survival by place of birth. Am J Epidemiol. 1985, 122: 571-578.
Minami Y, Takano A, Okuno Y, Fukao A, Kurihara M, Hisamichi S: Trends in the incidence of female breast and cervical cancers in Miyagi Prefecture, Japan, 1959–1987. Jpn J Cancer Res. 1996, 87: 10-17.
Tajima N, Tsukuma H, Oshima A: Descriptive epidemiology of male breast cancer in Osaka, Japan. J Epidemiol. 2001, 11: 1-7.
Zimmermann MB, Kohrle J: The impact of iron and selenium deficiencies on iodine and thyroid metabolism: biochemistry and relevance to public health. Thyroid. 2002, 12: 867-878. 10.1089/105072502761016494.
Birringer M, Pilawa S, Flohe L: Trends in selenium biochemistry. Nat Prod Rep. 2002, 6: 693-718. 10.1039/b205802m.
Polat MF, Taysi S, Gul M, Cikman O, Yilmaz I, Bakan E, Erdogan F: Oxidant/antioxidant status in blood of patients with malignant breast tumour and benign breast disease. Cell Biochem Funct. 2002, 20: 327-331. 10.1002/cbf.980.
Ching S, Ingram D, Hahnel R, Beilby J, Rossi E: Serum levels of micronutrients, antioxidants and total antioxidant status predict risk of breast cancer in a case control study. J Nutr. 2002, 132: 303-306.
Winkler R, Griebenow S, Wonisch W: Effect of iodide on total antioxidant status of human serum. Cell Biochem Funct. 2000, 18: 143-146. 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0844(200006)18:2<143::AID-CBF857>3.3.CO;2-R.
Gartner R, Gasnier BCH, Dietrich JW, Krebs B, Angstwurm MWA: Selenium supplementation in patients with autoimmune thyroiditis decreases thyroid peroxidase antibodies concentrations. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2002, 87: 1687-1691. 10.1210/jc.87.4.1687.
Duntas LH, Mantzou E, Koutras DA: Effects of a six month treatment with selenomethionine in patients with autoimmune thyroiditis. Eur J Endocrinol. 2003, 148: 389-393.
My thanks to Professor NJ O'Higgins, Mr EWM McDermott, Mr ADK Hill, Sr MJ Murray, Department of Surgery, University College Dublin (St Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin 4) and the staff of the Endocrine Laboratory, in particular Mr Derek F Smith, Principal Technician.
About this article
Cite this article
Smyth, P.P. The thyroid, iodine and breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res 5, 235 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1186/bcr638