Workshop on The Epidemiology of the ATMGene: Impact on Breast Cancer Risk and Treatment, Present Status and Future Focus, Lillehammer, Norway, 29 June 2002

The genetic disease ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) is characterized by hypersensitivity to ionizing radiation, by genomic instability, and by predisposition to cancer, especially breast cancer. Early reports estimated that 3.8% of breast cancer cases could be attributed to ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM) heterozygosity, with a possible range of 1–13%. If, as some evidence suggests, missense mutations may be responsible for the majority of breast cancer among ATM heterozygotes [1], then these often cited figures underestimate the actual prevalence of the gene since they were derived from studies of A-T patients where the prevalence of truncating mutations is high and the prevalence of missense mutations is low. Furthermore, although inconsistent, some studies suggest that the ATM gene may be associated with an increased risk of breast cancer as high as 15-fold [2–12].

This possible excess risk of breast cancer associated with ATM heterozygosity, and the known biochemical interactions between the protein products of the ATM and BRCA1 genes, are the basis for several genetic epidemiologic studies designed to reconcile these conflicting results and to clarify the role that the ATM gene plays in the etiology of breast cancer and other cancers. The international, multidisciplinary, National Cancer Institute-sponsored workshop was organized as a forum for discussion of these ongoing and planned epidemiological studies. The 45 invited participants are key collaborators on these studies, with expertise including molecular and clinical genetics, radiation biology and physics, epidemiology, biostatistics, pathology, and medicine. The following is a summary of projects presented.

JL Bernstein (Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, USA) presented an overview of the Women's Environmental, Cancer, and Radiation Epidemiology (WECARE) study (NCI-CA83178; for study investigators, see Appendix). The WECARE study http://146.203.34.23/atmstudy/front.html is an international, multicenter, population-based, genetic epidemiological study designed to test the hypothesis that the incidence of contralateral breast cancer is increased among women who are heterozygous for ATM and who received radiation therapy as treatment for their first primary breast cancer. The 700 'cases' are women with bilateral breast cancer, and the 1400 individually counter-matched 'controls' are women with unilateral breast cancer being identified and interviewed through population-based tumor registries in the United States and in Denmark.

The full spectrum of ATM mutations is examined using an efficient staged approach (denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography followed by sequencing), which has been standardized in all four laboratories performing the analyses. Lifetime exposure to radiation, including the radiation therapy scatter dose to the contralateral breast, is also assessed. The study's premise is that any important genetic factors (e.g. ATM gene mutations) and etiological factors for breast cancer (e.g. radiation exposure) will be more prevalent among women who already have a first primary cancer than they would be among women in the general population. The WECARE study thus presents a promising context for sorting out complex gene–environment interactions involved in breast carcinogenesis.

The overall objective of this study, as presented by R Haile (University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA; for study investigators see Appendix), is to determine whether subjects who are ATM heterozygotes have a higher than expected risk of cancer, with a primary focus on breast cancer. Collaborators in Argentina, Bulgaria, Canada, Costa Rica, Germany, Israel, Italy, Turkey, and the United States who have already identified A-T families are collecting and verifying the reported history of cancer in parents and grandparents of A-T cases. In addition, genetic testing for mutations in the ATM gene in these families will be conducted. Participating centers have at present collectively identified 461 A-T families. Also planned are exploratory analyses addressing the issue of the heterogeneity of risk between subgroups defined by country of origin and specific type of mutation. It is understood that an analysis combining all known data sets will be necessary to address questions of heterogeneity in an informative manner.

G Chenevix-Trench (Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Brisbane, Australia; for study investigators see Appendix) discussed studies of A-T families that suggest female obligate heterozygotes have an increased risk of breast cancer. Yet neither linkage analyses or mutation studies have provided supporting evidence for these studies.

Two recurrent mutations, 7271T>G and IVS10-6T>G, conferring an elevated risk were recently reported. These mutations were examined in a population-based, case–control series of breast cancer patients as well as in multiple-case breast cancer families. They found three multiple-case families in which one or other of these mutations segregated with breast cancer. The estimated average penetrance of these mutations was 60% (95% confidence interval, 32–90%) up to age 70 years, equivalent to a 16-fold (95% confidence interval, 6–38) increased risk. Functional analyses in heterozygous cell lines indicated that both mutations act in a dominant-negative manner.

The conclusion was that certain ATM gene mutations, mis-sense and truncating, are associated with a sufficiently high risk of breast cancer and that they can be found in multiple-case breast cancer families. These families also contained multiple cases of colorectal and gastric cancer, raising the possibility that these mutations also confer high risks for these cancer types.

Full mutation analysis of the ATM gene is now underway in a large panel of non-BRCA1/BRCA2 breast cancer families, as are kinase assays of lymphoblastoid cell lines from these families as a screen for dominant-negative mutations.

The extent to which ATM heterozygosity increases the risk of radiation-induced breast cancer is currently being explored, as presented by A Broeks (The Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; for study investigators see Appendix).

Three case–control studies were conducted, with cases defined as patients who developed breast cancer following therapeutic or diagnostic radiation before age 50 years. Study 1 consisted of 58 patients with contralateral breast cancer following therapeutic radiation for their first breast cancer. Study 2 included 40 patients with breast cancer following mantle-field irradiation for Hodgkin's disease. Finally, study 3 involved 30 patients who developed breast cancer after diagnostic mammographic screening following a diagnosis of benign breast disease. For each case, four age-matched controls were selected who received radiation exposure for the same disease or diagnostic procedure but who did not develop breast cancer.

The proportions of ATM heterozygotes were determined using the denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis mutation detection method. In study 1, a substantial number of ATM protein truncating mutations and a variety of missense mutations were detected, both among the cases and the control individuals. In a case–control setting, taking all risk factors into account, the results of these three studies were analyzed. It appears that ATM heterozygotes may have an increased risk (relative risk, 3.1) of developing a specific type of breast cancer, characterized by frequent bilateral occurrence, by early age at onset, and by long-term survival.

The expression of the ATM and p53 proteins has been studied in breast in situ carcinomas and in invasive carcinomas. The results presented by J Hall (International Agency for Research on Cancer, Lyon, France; for study investigators see Appendix) indicate that, in most of the sporadic breast carcinomas, the DNA damage response as well as also other signaling pathways activated by the ATM and p53 multifunctional proteins [13] were compromised. Consistent with this, ATM expression was dramatically reduced in approximately 30% of sporadic breast neoplasms [14]. The expression profiles of these and other proteins implicated in DNA double-strand break repair (BRCA1, NBS1, MRE11 and Rad50) are presently being assessed in breast tumors.

Additionally, molecular characterization of lymphoblastoid cell lines established from radiosensitive and nonradiosensitive patients is being used to investigate the role of alterations in the ATM gene as a risk factor in breast cancer development. In some cell lines, the level of cell survival and p53 induction after ionizing radiation exposure is lower than that observed in control cell lines, indicating an alteration in the ATM signaling pathway. Using the protein truncating tests and restriction endonuclease fingerprinting techniques, a variety of rare ATM sequence alterations and polymorphisms have been detected in cases. The frequency of these alterations and polymorphisms in control samples is under investigation to establish whether their presence is associated with either radiation sensitivity or increased breast cancer risk.

The primary purpose of this meeting was to bring together scientists from diverse disciplines who are currently engaged in research aimed at understanding the complexities of the ATM gene and its role in breast carcinogenesis. The encouraging preliminary results presented, coupled with the long-term opportunities afforded from these studies and the recent advances in genomics and molecular genetics technology, set the stage for reconciling the conflicting results of prior genetic and epidemiologic studies. It is the scientists' joint goal that these studies contribute to our understanding, in order to correctly assess the population frequency of various types of ATM mutations, to determine the correlation between ATM genotype and the breast (or other) cancer phenotype, to clarify the function of the A-T gene product within the radiation damage repair pathways and, importantly, to precisely identify major genetic and environmental effect modifiers. In turn, this information will allow direct evaluation of the proportion of breast cancer directly related to mutations in the ATM gene (population attributable risk), and will facilitate the design of appropriate preventive and therapeutic strategies targeted to a population at increased risk for developing breast cancer.