Skip to main content

Table 5 Key features of the protocols for comparison

From: Comparison of different commercial kits for HER2 testing in breast cancer: looking for the accurate cutoff for amplification

Feature

PathVysion

PharmDx

INFORM

CISH

Reagents

Preparation required

Ready to use

Ready to use

Ready to use

Stability of reagents

pH requires checking

OK

OK

OK

DAPI

Bright

Low intensity

Not provided

-

Background

Orange fluorescence

Strong; green fluorescence

Faint; green fluorescence

-

Stability of signal

Good

Rapid quenching of FITC signal

Good

Excellent

HER2 probe

Spectrum Orange; clear signal but high background fluorescence

Texas red; strong clear signal

FITC; strong clear signal

Chromogenic; peroxidase-based immunodetection, clear signal

CEP17 probe

FITC; very strong signal, with blurring of large signals

FITC; faint and transient

-

-

Tissue morphology

Poor definition; control with H&E to view areas of interest

Very poor definition; control with H&E to view areas of interest

Poor definition; control with H&E to view areas of interest

Good definition, allowing simultaneous analysis of amplification and histopathology

Microscope

Fluorescent

Fluorescent

Fluorescent

Normal light

Storage

1 year at -20°C

1 year at -20°C

1 year at -20°C

Long period at ambient temperature

Threshold

OK

OK

CISH threshold must be applied and borderline cases must be evaluated with a dual-probe method (5–10)

 
  1. DAPI, 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole; HER2, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2; CEP17, chromosome enumeration probe 17; FITC, fluorescein isothiocyanate; H&E, haematoxylin and eosin staining; CISH, chromogenic in situ hybridisation.